Of Lost.
I’m not quite sure how I feel about it. Actually, all three of us are not certain how we feel about it - to the point of “do we watch the new season?”
SPOILERS up to the end of Season two and speculation contained below!! (for real)
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
So it started when Shannon was killed. Leone and I kept saying “but when will they go over and see she isn’t dead?” Right?? Shannon isn’t dead. And then they buried her - and they STILL DIDN”T KNOW SHE WASN”T DEAD!
We’re still waiting on that one.
And of course, we added to that a few nights ago “oh, when will they realise Shannon and Libby are not dead.” I hated Shannon for so long. She finally started to get some character and they killed her. I loved Libby. They didn’t even milk the “she’s alive but won’t wake up and spill the beans on Micheal” angle. Why is Libby dead?
Seriously, did they let that Joe Sweeden guy write for them this year? (for non Buffy people - Joss Whedon)
Couple main things - plot holes, character inconsistencies, random killing of people after we like them and get their back story, and a vague feeling that there is no overarcing plan for the show.
Rather than trying to tie up a few things here or there, it is like they come in each week and think about how to twist off in further far flung directions. I picture them each with a different coloured crayone just waiting to draw their own loopy path from any of the dangling issues.
Also, a lack of a reliable vantage-point. Lock had that at times, Mr. Echo, Kate, etc. But really, the only one I can rely on is Sayid. Everyone else seems to have serious bouts of the Stupid. Like when Micheal came back and Jack was all like “oh yeah, let’s follow Micheal” and thank goodness for Sayid! THEY FORGET TOO QUICKLY! That whole part where Micheal pulled the gun on them? The part where Micheal seriously needs some anger management classes? Did he ever thank Sawyer for saving him on the raft? No. And although Sawyer struggles to be the bad guy, I’d take him over the wing-nutty ones.
And Jack is just a knob.
Issue number nine million - SILLY PLANS!
Why did they all not go on the boat to the other side of the island to get the Others? According to them it was for the element of surprise and to pretend they still trusted Micheal. Er, coming on the boat would have been a surprise!
And our favorite plot hole:
Oh, Lock and Henry are in lock down, must pry open big heavy door too hard to imagine. Lock gets crunched. “Henry - go through the OPEN VENT to the computer room” … er … why on earth wouldn’t Lock have done that before.
As Jim said “oh, this hard door isn’t working - just go use that open unlocked door we never bothered to even try.”
Okay. I’m done now.
I like the show on many levels, but they really need to clue in to the difference between ongoing plots and intrigue vs. making random shit up because it sounds cool. This show could carry a huge audience based on the characters. But killing off people doesn’t bring in new viewers - and just threatens to drive off the ones you do have. So there.